ok I’m getting a lot of questions about the N20 timing chain noise and replacement,,,,here are 2 short audio clips,,,,you can here a high pitched whine in both videos. one video is at 3000rpms,,,,and the other is reving the engine up and down,,,I sent both videos to BMW to get approval on the timing chain repairs.
Here I removed the valve cover and inspected from the top of the engine for any visual problem,,,I don’t know if you can see it in the picture,,,,on top of the chain you can see shiney marks,,,that is an indication the chain is rubbing on something,,,,those marks are not normally there.
Here the old timing chain and guide reins,,,the guide rails were broken.
Here you can see where they broke,,,,the two rails would normally be snapped together.
Here the old oil pump timing chain module,,,,this comes complete as you see it,,,,did not find anything wrong with this,,,but BMW wants us to replace it at the same time as the timing chain.
Here are the new timing chain guides and rails,,,the new ones are white in color and made of a better plastic we hope,,,,lol.
This is the new oil pump timing chain module complete just bolt in,,,,this job is not one of the best to do,,,,this was on a X3 so I had to deal with the front axles and front differential,,,,,this job only pays about 9.5 hours,,,so you pretty much have one day to complete the job to make any money.,,,I hope this helps some of you guys about the timing chain issues.
-
Recent Comments
bmwtechnician on My little helper died bmwtechnician on N20 timing chain issue bmwtechnician on N20 timing chain issue Omar on My little helper died Daniel on N20 timing chain issue
Thank you for all of the great info. I recently purchased a 5/2012 X3 XDrive 28i 2013 and my daughter drove it to school. Now I’m trying to figure out if the guides and chain have already been replaced by her pictures. Carfax is the only history I have and it does not specifically state that the job was done. Would it be common for warranty work to be done and not doc umented? Do the pictures look correct, and does the chain look like it has stress to you? She does not hear the sound during engine revs. Thanks, Dave (Nervous Dad)
https://ibb.co/xzYggqT
https://ibb.co/Zc5ysYQ
https://ibb.co/g6KnvFm
LikeLike
Thanks for the picture,,,any warranty work done by the dealer is documented,,,what you need to do is go to the dealership and have them do a key read on your car and get a print out of what repairs were done by the dealership.,,,from the pictures it’s hard to say what condition the timing chain is in.,,,you could have the dealership performed a timing chain test for piece of mind.
LikeLike
Thanks for the feedback. Does the plastic look like the newer part?
LikeLike
The plastic does look newer
LikeLike
Dave, I’ve got the same exact car and I am also concerned about this issue. I don’t know if mine has the new guards installed, seems like the previous owner had that issue and somehow fixed it. I took it to BMW service today and they told me it was diagnosed needing a new engine last year! but it is still running, so I am guessing they did repair it somehow but I don’t have those records.
How did you take those pics? did you have your daughter introduce a camera in the engine?
LikeLike
You can ask the dealer for a print out of repairs on your car to see if the timing chain was replaced at a dealership.,,,,if it was done at a independent then there would be no records of that repair
LikeLike
Any indication on this one?
https://streamable.com/l3a4fl
Just purchased from a BMW dealer @70k miles. They offer a 100% 60 day warranty. Should I try and have them replace it? Thank you.
LikeLike
Thanks for the video,,,,yes have them replace it and fix it correctly
LikeLike
Hello there, I just bought a 2014 328i off the BMW dealership with 79k miles would all carfax were good would you recommend changing the timing chain ⛓and guids now? Or at a later milage?
LikeLike
The sooner then later,,,there is a new timing chain recall coming out in June which might not cost you anything to replace
LikeLike
The whine is all the time,,,the whine will change while raving the engine,,,it’s also there while driving,,,,the noise is easier to hear while standing in front of the car
LikeLike
Im thinking about buying a bmwx3 28i 2016 or 17 has there been any reports of timing chain breaking
LikeLike
2016 yes,,,2017 not that I know of
LikeLike
Hi Andreas, I got the class action settlement letter from BMWNA, do u know much about the cost of repairing N20/N26 timing chain at dealer? Since the letter says owner has to pay a % of the repair cost, so I am wondering if BMWNA has a suggested price(like MSRP?) for this specific repair.
LikeLike
No I’m sorry they don’t tell us the prices on repairs.
LikeLike
hello i have a question, after taking the valve cover off on my n20 engine i found out that intake cam is about 90 degrees my inspection camera shows that no markings on the piston
has anyone gotten lucky ? can i change the chain and be back to running engine?
LikeLike
timing chain has jumped
LikeLike
Yes a lot of people have gotten lucky by just replacing the timing chain and rails.
LikeLike
Just received a Class-Action Notice against BMW regarding the below defects which could lead to sudden engine failure, model years 2012-2015 (my car 320i 2013): 1. Failed timing chain module 2. Failed oil pump drive chain module 3. And or failed engine due to the failure of 1 & 2 above According to the Notice, I MAY BE entitled to reimbursement for past expenses provided under the settlement. If BMW knew of the defects, why wasn’t a re-call issued? Now I have to spend my $ dollars and hope I will be reimbursed once the judge makes a final decision. If the defects aren’t fixed I’m putting my life in “Jeopardy” by continuing to drive this defected vehicle. This is so Totally Unacceptable! And to top it off, there was excessive smoke coming from my exhaust after sitting overnight. I was told the turbo oil feed line had to be replaced. Did some research online and found many BMW owners with this same problem, this too should have been a re-call issue. Does the Oil Feed line have anything to do with the failed oil pump drive defect?
LikeLike
The turbo oil feed line was a recall on certain models and years which I don’t understand,,,and no the turbo oil feed line doesn’t have anything to do with the oil pump or timing chain
LikeLike
Thank you!
LikeLike
Sheila,
I found this post after searching a little after my dealer/service department told me my 2013 BMW 328i cannot be fixed without a large motor inspection. It shut off on me while driving and would never crank back. It turned over just fine, but would never start. After being in the shop for over a week, that’s the call I got today. This is a huge cost and the service manager said it may not be even worth fixing. The car is immaculate but does have 170k miles on it. I was first told it was probably the STP oil filter used in the last oil change at Firestone since it wasn’t OEM. That seemed quite weird to me. Then this. Im at a loss frankly. I sure hope this turns out to be good for everyone.
Scott
LikeLike
I’m sorry to hear what happened to your vehicle,,,I have always been saying BMW should have done something about this engine and the failure and money that has cost to fix it.
LikeLike
Thanks Scott! This is actually great I’m taking my car into the dealership today!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I recently bought a 428i convertible. I had the dealer check the timing chain and they say there is no slack and everything looks good. What should I do, my 7/70 warranty expires in 2 months? I do not currently have a whine, but the guides are definitely the orange/brown color, so I assume are the most likely to fail.
LikeLike
2014
LikeLike
You should be concerned about the timing chain issue,,,maybe see if the dealer can replace it before the warranty is up.
LikeLike
What year is your car
LikeLike
They say they won’t replace it without seeing an issue.
LikeLike
That sucks,,,some dealer will replace it without any issues ,,because they know there is a problem.
LikeLike
Is the F25 N55 engine effected by the timing chain issue?
LikeLike
Nope
LikeLike
Took my car into the dealer no noise heard from the timing chain, some slack found when picking up chain through oil fill, what the hell does that mean?
LikeLike
Some slack is normal in the chain.
LikeLike
2013. I was told the same thing by Car Shield. My dealer has to break the car down to allow Car Shield to inspect the issue. Thinking seriously about trading this car!
LikeLike
If you don’t feel safe in your car which I don’t blame you,,,I wouldn’t feel safe myself with the N20 engine.,,,so trading it in might not be a bad thing
LikeLike
Hi, I have a 2014 328i xdrive, build date is 09/2013, with 55k, my question is about the timing chain issue, I don’t hear any noise but am worried about it going after the 7/70 expires, which is April 2021, what should I do??
LikeLike
See if you can get a dealership to replace it if you can
LikeLike
Hi, i have a 2014 420i F33 with 23000miles. I am thinking about replacing the original timing chain tensioner with the latest ‘upgraded’ version which seems to have a stronger ‘push’ on the guides/chain. Will this cause my guides/chain to wear out quicker, or is it the original tensioner that actually fails causing the chain/guides to fail.
LikeLike
The original tensioner doesn’t fail,,,the timing chain and guide rails are the issue
LikeLike
I have a bmw f30 330d with the N57 engine,are the timing chains known to fail on this engine ?
LikeLike
Nope,,,only on the N20 and N26 engines
LikeLike
I am interested in buying a 2017 328D with 25k miles. In your opinion, would you have any concerns regarding the ‘updated’ timing chain/guide (or any other potential major issue) with this model? Buy with confidence or run away?
LikeLike
The 328D diesel doesn’t have timing chain issues,,,the thing I worry about is the emissions stuff on the diesel,,,,like the NOX sensors, EGR,,,,, I would walk away because the car doesn’t have any BMW warranty and that car could get expensive on repairs
LikeLike
I am looking at a few different 328i vehicles. One is a 2013 model year that according to the owner has had the timing chain replaced back ion 2017. It currently has 100,000 miles on it. Do you think this is a safe bet/candidate. The other two are 2015 model years, one has 53000 miles the other 72000. Nothing shows on the Carfax to indicate that the timing belt has been replaced, however, having read this thread I will be taking a look at the guides to determine the coloration to try and determine if the chain has been replaced. Is there any other way that this can be determined.
Thanks in advance for any advice you can offer.
LikeLike
I would stay away from the 2013 and 100k,,,,I would go for the 2015 53k if you can,,,there really isn’t anyway to to tell what condition the timing chain is in.,,try and make sure the car had all the oil changes performed
LikeLike
I have a 2013 528i. Suddenly my engine light came on and i took it to the dealer. Was told my engine is out of time. The chain is moving inside my engine. The oil filter had a large amount of plastic material and metal shavings inside. Was told that it would cost me 16,000 to replace the engine. My car has 109k miles on it. No warranty. So if this is an issue with these cars why isn’t the company taking care of it. I sure don’t have 16k to put into a car for a engine! There needs to be a recall on this and BMW needs to take care of this issue!!!
LikeLike
I know this is a bad design on BMW,,,I know there is a law suit about this issue if you can find it on the internet
LikeLike
i think all of europe is awash in cheap plastics — probably the EU mandates self destruction because of the fake climate agenda
LikeLike
I did find the lawsuit on the web. But from what I read, unfortunately anybody with a vehicle over 100k miles is out of luck. This is so unfair. Even worse, I just purchased this vehicle this past summer.
LikeLike
I’m really sorry,,,this whole thing wasn’t handled very well from BMW
LikeLike
Does this sound like timing chain whine? 2014 320i xDrive with 85k kms. Still under timing chain warranty for another few weeks!
LikeLike
Thanks for the video,,,yes that is the start of the timing chain whine
LikeLike
Thanks for all your help, is this the timing chain whine??
https://youtube.com/shorts/pJiwt7SWxeg
LikeLike
Thanks for the video,,,and yes that is the whine noise from the timing chain
LikeLike
I appreciate your response. What should my next step be? Will BMW still cover my car under warranty? I’m at 57k miles and my manufacture date is November 2014. I didnt buy this car from a BMW dealership, but from what I understand the warranty goes by the vin number no matter who the owner is. Is that correct? Should I park the car till I can get it looked at ? Or is it still driveable until I can get it to a shop? Thanks again , your help is very appreciated.
LikeLike
I appreciate your response. What should my next step be? Will BMW still cover my car under warranty? I’m at 57k miles and my manufacture date is November 2014. I didnt buy this car from a BMW dealership, but from what I understand the warranty goes by the vin number no matter who the owner is. Is that correct? Should I park the car till I can get it looked at ? Or is it still driveable until I can get it to a shop? Thanks again , your help is very appreciated.
LikeLike
Your engine is still covered by 7 years/70000 miles N20/N26 timing chain extended limited warranty, so just bring the car to dealer and confirm the high pitch whining, and the repair should be free to owner.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Update , I purchased the x3 with jumped timing in non running installed new updated kit reset adaptations it’s now running beautifully !!!!
Sent from my iPhone
>
LikeLike
Glad to here it,,,it’s alive
LikeLike
Thanks for the reply . I was already freaking out a little so I contacted bmwna through email. They responded today telling me the same thing. Now I need to find someone to tow it 20 miles without charging me out the ass lol. Thanks again .
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes the extended warranty of 7/70 on the timing chain issue is by certain vin numbers,,,,check with your dealership
LikeLike
I hate to keep bugging you about this . But is the timing chain whine enough proof for BMW to fix my timing chain and other parts u der warranty? The SA I talked to at my local dealer basically said the parts need to be broken or the warranty wont cover my car. I’m just confused . I. Hearing alot of conflicting stories about using the warranty . And different dealerships being dishonest to customers.
LikeLike
No problem,,,each dealership seems to be different,,,some will replace it because of the whine noise and some won’t,,,,it just doesn’t make any sense to me because it’s money that goes to the dealership for the repairs and they no it’s a problem,,,maybe try a different dealership if you can.
LikeLike
Heres an update: I just dropped my BMW off at the not so local dealership ( 25miles away) . I’ve never stepped foot in this building before . I didnt even buy my car here and these guys knew it. The SA and shop foreman I talked to treated me like a 20+year customer. The shop foreman assured me he would do everything he could to get my timing chain fixed, and I believe him . They complimented my 2015 328ix on the mileage (56k) miles as well as the condition and paint job( still Factory) . This interaction has restored my faith in BMW even given the fact this is my 1st BMW bought from a dodge dealership lol. After reading a few horror stories online I was almost ready to dump mine and run away from a BMW for the rest of my life. I can guarantee the my next car will be a BMW from my local dealership.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your 2015@56k miles is still covered by 7 years/70k miles N20/N26 timing chain extended limited warranty per VIN, so BMWNA will fix any TC issue as $0 cost to you(assuming oil changes were done on schedule). 🙂
LikeLike
I bought the car with 45k miles . I’ve changed the oil 3 times. About every 3500 miles . I believe I read in the timing chain settlement that I only need to show the OCI from the time I purchased the car. So The SA did a keyread and the first 3.5 years had a full service history at a BMW dealership In another state. The next 1.5 years has 1 oil change on record at BMW between 30k and 45k miles . So either way I think I’ll be in good shape.
LikeLike
Nice,,I’m glad you had a good experience
LikeLike
I’m looking at a 2013 X1 with 75k miles on it. Is this vehicle outside the 7 year/ 70k mile warranty? It sounds like a rhetorical question, but I thought I had seen that BMW extended that warranty. Is this true or should I stay away from this car? Thank you kindly.
LikeLike
Stay away from the car.,,,no they did not extended the warranty
LikeLike
Or you could budget the price of replacing the chain & guides into the purchase price & just get them replaced?
LikeLike
You could do that if the price is right
LikeLike
That’s what i did when i bought my F33. As long as I acknowledged that at some point I would need to spend £1000ish to get the chains & guides done, why would i let that stop me buying a car that i really wanted? Some people pay way more than that just to change it’s colour, or it’s wheels. Doesn’t seem a problem to me.
LikeLike
Sounds good
LikeLike
Sorry if this has been answered. I just found out about this issue, 2015 328i with 73k miles manufactured in 02/2015. Do I have the redesigned timing chain?
LikeLike
Yes you have the newer timing chain
LikeLike
Really appreciate your response. Thank you.
LikeLike
Does an X1 with date of 05/2015 have the correct chain guides? Thank you.
LikeLike
Yes it should
LikeLike
So I have a 2014 320i x drive and I am almost certain with its 88k miles it needs to have the timing chain fixed, should I go take it into a shop to get it done? Also is there anything else I should worry about with this car, I keep getting a check engine light when it gets cold and when I pull the code it says the thermostat is open but my engine still warms up and the check engine light disappears when it starts to warm up again. Any thoughts on what I should do?
LikeLike
I would hold off if you can and not drive the car ,,,, because we just got noticed that BMW is going to have a major timing chain recall mileage won’t matter,,,check in with your dealership
LikeLiked by 1 person
Please tell me this is not just a rumor.
LikeLike
It’s going to happen
LikeLiked by 1 person
Just searched online to see if there is any updated info on the 4 cylinder chain. I did find where BMW “replaced” timing chains on their V8 engine 2008-2014 vehicles. BMW has changed some in the last several years and I’m not really sure it is for the better.
https://www.bmwblog.com/2015/10/28/bmw-to-replace-faulty-timing-chain-in-2008-2014-vehicles/
LikeLike
We have a 2014 X3 with the N20, and 136,000 miles. The car has been driven like a baby (mostly “living” at 1800 rpm or so) and have had no issues. Just became aware of this problem because our other BMW – 2013 328i x-drive with 90,000+ miles – is being prepped to give as a graduation gift to our daughter, and our mechanic (not BMW, but fabulous mechanic) replaced its chains. He’s ex-husband and the girl’s Dad, so no charge to us. He said the chain was totally loose and flopping. Was surprised it hadn’t failed. I hope you’re right about BMW recall, because I’m calling our dealer tomorrow to see if the X3 will get covered!
LikeLike
The recall should be out by late June
LikeLike
Will this recall be only for the US, or worldwide? Thanks!
LikeLike
Hopefully worldwide, it would be grossly unfair if BMW singled out certain countries when the engines are the same everywhere.
LikeLike
I hope it covers everyone
LikeLike